Prosecutors will stack on charges because it provides them with leverage. When the District Attorney’s Office files multiple charges for a single incident, it is a calculated move designed to cast a wide net and build immense pressure against a defendant. At SKA Law Group, our criminal defense attorneys, including Attorney William A. Weiss, understand exactly how to counter these aggressive prosecutorial tactics and protect your future in Montgomery County courts.
How Charge Stacking Works
Charging decisions are highly discretionary, meaning prosecutors can bring one charge—or ten—depending on how they want to position the case. This practice, known as charge stacking, involves dividing a single criminal event into multiple distinct statutory violations. It is an extremely common tactic; in fact, an estimated 86% of criminal cases in the Commonwealth involve two or more charges.
The ultimate goal for the prosecution is not necessarily to secure a conviction on every single count, but to win on something. Facing a towering list of charges significantly increases a defendant’s perceived risk and exposure at trial. Prosecutors use this manufactured uncertainty to their advantage, leveraging the threat of multiple convictions to make plea deals appear far more attractive than they normally would.
How Does Charge Stacking Affect a Sentence
If you are facing a stack of charges, it is crucial to understand your actual legal exposure. Under the merger statute (42 Pa.C.S.A. § 9765), sentences do not automatically merge just because the charges stem from a single criminal incident. Crimes only merge for sentencing purposes if they arise from a single act and all the statutory elements of one offense are completely included in the statutory elements of the other.
This means that if each crime requires proof of an element that the other does not, the charges will not merge. As a result, a judge is permitted to impose separate sentences for each conviction, which could run consecutively (one after another). Because sentences do not automatically merge, aggressive defense representation is absolutely critical to avoid multiple punishments for a single event.
How William A. Weiss Helps You in Your Case
In Montgomery County, criminal cases generally start by an arrest or a summons mailed to the defendant. The fight against overcharging begins early at the preliminary hearing. This hearing takes place in front of a Magisterial District Judge, where the Commonwealth has the burden of presenting a prima facie case—meaning they must produce enough evidence to show a crime was likely committed by the defendant.
The preliminary hearing is the first substantive step in the criminal process and the most critical opportunity to preview and challenge the government’s evidence. William A. Weiss and the legal team at SKA Law Group aggressively use this stage to question potential witnesses and challenge unsupported charges before they are ever held for trial in the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County.
By dismantling the prosecution’s leverage early in the legal process, or negotiating favorable terms that may involve Montgomery County’s Alternative Courts (such as Veterans Court or Behavioral Health Court), we protect you from the overwhelming weight of overbuilt cases.
FAQs: What is Charge Stacking and How Does it Work?
Q: What exactly is charge stacking?
A: Charge stacking is the practice of prosecutors bringing as many relevant criminal charges as possible against a defendant for a single incident. Prosecutors use this strategy to build pressure, increase a defendant’s potential sentencing exposure, and leverage favorable plea deals.
Q: Will my sentences automatically merge if I am convicted of multiple charges?
A: No. Under the merger statute (42 Pa.C.S.A. § 9765), crimes only merge for sentencing if they stem from a single act and all of the statutory elements of one offense are completely included in the other. If the charges have different legal elements, they do not merge, and you could face separate, consecutive punishments.
Q: What happens at a preliminary hearing in Montgomery County?
A: The preliminary hearing is the first substantive step in the criminal process where a Magisterial District Judge decides if the Commonwealth has presented a prima facie case (enough evidence that a crime was committed). It is not a trial to determine guilt, but rather a critical opportunity for your defense attorney to preview evidence, question witnesses, and challenge the charges against you.
Q: How can William A. Weiss at SKA Law Group help defend against stacked charges?
A: Attorney William A. Weiss and the team at SKA Law Group can aggressively challenge the government’s evidence at your preliminary hearing before a Magisterial District Judge. We focus on highlighting evidentiary weaknesses and filing motions in the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County to have baseless, duplicative charges reduced or entirely dismissed.
Leave a Reply